Carolann M. Aschoff P.C.

Jersey City and Bayonne 201-793-7739   |   Livingston 973-200-4892

  • Home
  • About
    • Firm Overview
    • Carolann M. Aschoff
    • Annmarie Jensen
  • Practice Areas
    • Divorce
    • Family Law
    • Mediation
    • Wills
  • The 2% Advantage
    • The Benefits of Hiring An Experienced Lawyer
  • Locations
    • Bayonne Family Law Office
    • Jersey City Family Law Office
    • Livingston Family Law Office
      • Livingston Divorce Lawyer
      • Livingston Mediation Lawyer
  • Blog
  • Contact
Carolann M. Aschoff, P.C.
  • Home
  • About
    • Firm Overview
    • Carolann M. Aschoff
    • Annmarie Jensen
  • Practice Areas
    • Divorce
    • Family Law
    • Mediation
    • Wills
  • The 2% Advantage
    • The Benefits of Hiring An Experienced Lawyer
  • Locations
    • Bayonne Family Law Office
    • Jersey City Family Law Office
    • Livingston Family Law Office
      • Livingston Divorce Lawyer
      • Livingston Mediation Lawyer
  • Blog
  • Contact

 201-793-7739

Experience The 2% Advantage: Certified Matrimonial Law Protection For Your Family

New Jersey Supreme Court | Seal of the Supreme Court of New Jersey | Certified Attorney
  1. Home
  2.  | 
  3. Mediation
  4.  | 
  5. What happens if spouses can’t agree during divorce mediation?

What happens if spouses can’t agree during divorce mediation?

On Behalf of Carolann M. Aschoff, P.C. | Nov 26, 2025 | Mediation

Mediation is a form of alternative dispute resolution. When spouses agree to mediate their divorce, the goal is typically to compromise and move forward with an uncontested filing.

When mediation is successful, spouses reach terms that they both deem acceptable and integrate those terms into a binding agreement. That document can then guide the paperwork submitted to the court.

Unfortunately, spouses who can’t agree about key aspects of their divorce may find that mediation is not as effective as they had hoped. Sometimes, spouses walk away from mediation sessions feeling frustrated. What happens when mediation doesn’t lead to an agreement?

Additional sessions are often necessary

After years of marriage, spouses may not be able to settle everything quickly. Especially in cases involving allegations of misconduct or complex resources, spouses may have a lot to unpack during confidential mediation sessions.

It is common for divorcing couples to require between three and five mediation sessions to work out a reasonable settlement. While some couples reach an agreement after a single session or only a few sessions, others have to work for weeks to reach terms that are appropriate and fair given the marital circumstances.

Litigation is still an option

Mediation requires a cooperative approach to divorce negotiations. Spouses must act in good faith, or mediation may not be successful. In scenarios where one spouse has behaved manipulatively or been untruthful during mediation, continuing to try to settle outside of court might not be reasonable.

In cases where there are questions about the accuracy of financial disclosures, for example, litigation can be a critical form of protection for the spouse dealing with deceptive conduct and financial misrepresentation. Although mediation can be successful even in complex divorces and cases involving high levels of conflict, sometimes spouses recognize that they simply cannot cooperate with one another despite their best intentions.

When mediation is not successful, the spouses have to begin preparing for litigation. In a litigated divorce, a judge applies state statutes to settle disagreements between spouses.

Having legal guidance during divorce mediation can make it easier for spouses to compromise as necessary and recognize when continuing to mediate isn’t appropriate. Spouses who know what to expect can approach mediation with confidence and move on to litigation if necessary.

Recent Posts

  • Does dating someone new affect a pending divorce?
  • Are you liable for your ex-spouse’s debts after a divorce?
  • Boutique law firm vs. large firm: What really sets them apart?
  • 4 signs a marriage qualifies for an annulment
  • How can parents share legal custody after a divorce?

Categories

Archives

RSS Feed

Subscribe To This Blog's Feed

Connect With Our Office

Carolann M. Aschoff, P.C.

Phone

201-793-7739 (Jersey City and Bayonne locations)

973-200-4892 (Livingston location)

Jersey City Office

295 Newark Avenue
Jersey City, NJ 07302

  Jersey City Office Location

Bayonne Office

503 John F. Kennedy Blvd.
Bayonne, NJ 07002
  Bayonne Office Location

Livingston Office

354 Eisenhower Parkway
Plaza Two, The second floor, suite # 2575
Livingston, NJ 07039

  Livingston Family Law Office

Social Media

  • Follow
  • Follow
  • Follow
Review Our Firm

© 2026 Carolann M. Aschoff, P.C. • All Rights Reserved

Disclaimer | Site Map | Privacy Policy | Business Development Solutions by FindLaw